Empty Gestures: How to Avoid Phony Employee Recognition
Engaged workers stay with their employer.
Employee recognition is an essential part of any organization’s employee engagement and retention strategy. But watch out for phony employee recognition.
According to Gallup “Engaged workers are more likely to stay with their employer.” Recognition helps to create a positive work environment by introducing a bit of fun to the workplace and by building morale.
Not all recognition is appropriate. It can sometimes feel fake or empty. Sometimes it can feel forced and like phony employee recognition.
Let’s take a look at what may make recognition phony and how you can avoid it by focusing on genuine, inclusive as well as incentive-based appreciation.
Engaged workers also are more likely to stay with their employers. In high-turnover organizations, highly engaged business units achieve an 18% difference in turnover. In low-turnover organizations, the gains are even more dramatic: Highly engaged business units achieve a 43% difference in turnover…
Gallup Workplace:
Employee Engagement vs. Employee Satisfaction and Organizational Culture
Understanding Phony Employee Recognition
Recognition comes off as phony when the appreciation feels insincere or meaningless. It may also seem phony when recognition is just a single, once-in-lifetime, low-value occurrence. Here are a few examples to watch out for:
Infrequent Recognition: Just having a recognition event once. For example, you can’t just have a single pizza party for the entire year. Pizza parties are great, but a single one gets employees focused on how cheap it seems and is considered phony employee recognition. A regular pizza party in a series of weekly, monthly or quarterly recognition gatherings is much more effective.
Generic Praise: It’s great to thank everyone for their hard work and dedication, but it pays to be specific. Don’t just give out generalized, generic thanks. Instead of thanking everyone for their hard work, be specific. “We achieved our quarterly growth target, so let’s celebrate!” Single out a few folks deserving of special recognition and be specific about their achievements.
Token Gifts: Everybody loves a small gift! But be careful not to just give out the same small, impersonal rewards to everyone, like a branded T-shirt or a branded pen. Sure, these can be appropriate and appreciated, but not if it’s the only incentive gift you will give out in a year.
Superficial Acknowledgment: Merely mentioning someone’s name in a meeting or an email without providing the full details and context about their achievements is a wasted opportunity.
Rote Awards: Rote awards like “Employee of the Month” quickly become inauthentic and routine. When awards become too routine, they lose impact and are perceived as just another box to check. It’s far better to find reasons to acknowledge employees for specific achievements and contributions.
Why Authentic Recognition Matters
Provide a Sense of Value
Genuine recognition shows real appreciation for an employee’s hard work and achievements. It is specific. Genuine recognition gives employees a sense of value and helps to keep them motivated. Here are some benefits of genuine recognition:
Increased Motivation: When employees feel appreciated, they are more likely to stay motivated and productive.
Higher Job Satisfaction: Genuine recognition can make employees feel happier and more satisfied with their jobs.
Better Team Dynamics: When recognition is sincere, it can improve relationships and teamwork among employees.
Improved Morale: Creating a positive and supportive work environment where individuals feel valued and respected can significantly improve morale.
Employee Retention: Employees who feel valued are less likely to leave the company, reducing turnover rates.
How to Avoid Phony Employee Recognition
Genuine appreciation and meaningful incentives go a long way to preventing phony employee recognition. Here are some strategies:
Consistent Events: Schedule events and get-togethers, either in-person or remotely on a consistent basis, whether it’s monthly, quarterly, or at another interval that suits your team. It’s a good platform to use to add in a bit of recognition and praise when it is appropriate and earned.
Be Specific: When you recognize an employee or recognize a team, be as specific as possible about what they did well. Avoid just using generic praise like, “Great job.” Instead praise them for “excellent work leading the XYZ project and organizing the team to meet our deadline.”
Be Timely: Recognize an employee for their contribution as soon as possible after the achievement. Let everyone know you are paying attention and that you value their efforts in real-time.
Personalize Recognition: Tailor your recognition to the individual. Some employees might appreciate public praise, while others might prefer a private note or a one-on-one conversation.
Regular Feedback: Make recognition a regular part of your routine. Regular feedback, both positive and constructive, helps employees understand that their work is always being noticed and appreciated.
Create a Recognition Program: Consider establishing a formal recognition program where employees can nominate peers for praise and be rewarded. Make sure the program is transparent, fair, and involves input from various levels within the organization.
Celebrate Milestones: Recognize and celebrate important milestones, such as work anniversaries, project completions, or personal achievements. This shows that you are paying attention to their journey and progress.
Use Meaningful Incentives: Use incentives along with your praise. Provide incentives that are meaningful and valuable to your employees. Avoid phony employee recognition.
Here are some ideas:
Bonuses and Raises: Financial rewards can be a strong motivator. Consider giving bonuses or raises based on performance.
Gift Cards: While generic gift cards can feel impersonal, choosing ones that align with the employee’s interests can make them more meaningful. For example, a gift card to a favorite restaurant or store.
Extra Time Off: Offering extra vacation days or allowing flexible work hours can be a highly appreciated reward.
Professional Development: Investing in an employee’s future by paying for courses, workshops, or conferences can show that you value their growth and career development.
Personalized Gifts and Merchandise: Consider giving personalized gifts that reflect the employee’s hobbies or interests. For example, if an employee loves coffee, a high-quality coffee maker or a subscription to a gourmet coffee service could be a thoughtful gift.
Recognition: Use a mix of public and private recognition. Public recognition can boost an employee’s status among peers, while private recognition can feel more sincere and personal.
Avoiding Common Mistakes and Pitfalls
There are a few simple things to avoid. Even when you have the best intentions, there are a few common traps that make recognition seem phony. Here are some common pitfalls to avoid:
Overdoing It
Too much recognition can dilute its value. Make sure recognition is appropriate, meaningful and not overused.
Ignoring Quiet Achievers
Some employees might not seek attention but still do excellent work. Make an effort to recognize everyone, not just the most vocal or visible employees.
Focusing Only on Results
Recognize not just the outcomes but also the effort and process. Acknowledge hard work, creativity, and perseverance, even when the final result wasn’t perfect.
Same Old, One-Size-Fits-All Approach
Avoid using the same type of recognition for everyone. Tailor your approach to fit individual preferences and needs.
Avoid Phony Employee Recognition
Genuine employee recognition is a powerful tool for building a positive and productive workplace.
Avoid phony gestures and focusing on providing meaningful, incentive-based appreciation to your employees. You can show your employees that their efforts are truly valued.
Remember to be specific, timely, and personalized in your recognition. Use a variety of incentives and make recognition a regular practice.
Build a culture of recognition, and create an environment where employees feel motivated, satisfied, and eager to contribute their best.
Incentives play a crucial role in making recognition meaningful. Whether it’s through financial rewards, personalized gifts, professional development opportunities, or extra time off, choosing the right incentives can make a significant impact.
Ensure that your recognition efforts are genuine and effective, fostering a happy and productive workplace for all.
Ready to design something brilliant?
Schedule a free design session
Our design sessions are the perfect way to show you how TruCentive can help you realize your rewards, gifts, or payout goals in a real-world scenario, building a complete project with everything from your logo, design options, and messaging to incentive selection, deliveries, and reminders.
When we’re done, you’ll:
- Possess a solid grasp of constructing your project.
- Have a comprehensive understanding of best practices for incentive delivery.
- Learn the secrets of the incentives industry and the savings and advantages of utilizing TruCentive for your next program.
If you’re ready to start designing on your own, sign up and start sending samples. There’s no credit card required to start exploring your creative side!
Create “Grade-A” content
Use powerful features to quickly create professional-looking incentive deliveries
At your service
With a TruCentive subscription, you get technical support for all your team members so you can get back to your project fast
Reimagine your productivity
Eliminate the time and frustration managing the procurement, delivery, and management of your rewards and incentives deliveries
